I wouldn't be opposed to having the Top 4 from each division. Last year in 2nd grade my team went 6-2 and finished tied for 2nd. We had 3 teams tied at 6-2. We would have missed the playoffs if we were in 3rd grade because we had scored fewer points than the 2 teams above us. However, we shut out the top of the 2nd place teams 27-0 in the last game of the season. So I wouldn't mind if the Top 4 made it. It is what it is though...