Author Topic: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............  (Read 3017 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

guest3912

  • Guest
Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« on: October 08, 2016, 10:26:07 am »
I'm sick and tired of watching coaches conduct their practices during the week, then watching them lose on Saturday.  I don't mind the losing.  What I DO mind is, after the game, the coaches don't take the ANY of the responsibility for the loss!  Instead, they very pointedly blame the kids, trying to lay a guilt trip on them for the coaches' failure to prepare! 

The kids suffer through inept practices which involve more talking than coaching, meaningless drills, (when the coaches aren't talking) and total lack of effective discipline which undermines team unity and motivation.  Kids learn little from speeches and continual demonstration by coaches who may know their “stuff,” but don't plan for the kids to DO! They learn to block and tackle by having drills which teach those skills, not by some guy TELLING them how to do it!  Endlessly running thru plays and TALKING about techniques doesn't get it done.

I've seen kids with tons of potential be shunted aside because they don't have immediate skills, yet no one spends time TEACHING them anything except how to be a blocking dummy while the more skilled - favored - players are running plays. 

On these teams, there is NO one-on-one competition between kids for positions on the team.  Instead of drills pitting players competing against each other by demonstrating – and improving - their skills, the coaches per-determine which players will fill any one position and use the others on the “dummy squad.”  And the less-skilled kid with potential gets NO opportunity to improve by doing, since the coaches are TALKING a good game and ignoring their responsibility to instruct and develop ALL the team members. 

I realize many coaches are there because their kid is a talented athlete.  But standing around and jaw-boning with other, similar “coaches” instead of teaching fundamentals to ALL team members doesn't qualify them as coaches.  They are pawns who have brought their talented boy into a closed system with little chance for the un-developed player to become otherwise.  And for ANY “coach” to vilify their players for losing – mostly because of lack of proper preparation during the week – is intolerable! 

You know yourselves and your own team, coaches.  Are you coaching, or are you posturing?  Are you preparing ALL your team members to improve and be productive, or have you decided which players can help you win NOW?  Are you failing to give others the chance to improve to the point of possibly becoming valuable talent in coming years?  If you're coaching for all the wrong reasons, you owe it to the kids to get out and quit posing as something you aren't...........

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter

Like Like x 1 Agree Agree x 1 View List

FootballOCD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1588
  • Karma: +157/-57
  • Making Champions on and off the field!
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #1 on: October 08, 2016, 08:32:14 pm »
Where I could possibly see your grief ...have a question.

Why aren't you coaching?
Lets Eat!

5th grade Pryor

A CHAMPION is simply someone who did NOT give up when they wanted to."--Tom Landry,

LEAVE NO DOUBT!!!!

Shhhhhh don't tell nobody....

guest3626

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #2 on: October 08, 2016, 09:36:32 pm »
Wow sounds like your anger should be directed at a specific coach. Anyone can coach from the stands and think they have it figured out. Pick up a whistle and volunteer your hours away from your family to be a positive in youth athletics instead of being know it all complainer on a smart phone. You are the problem with youth athletics!  Want change be a change.
Agree Agree x 1 View List

clark13

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1091
  • Karma: +75/-29
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #3 on: October 09, 2016, 09:07:15 am »
Before you complain...... Volunteer
If it don't challenge you it dont change you

Hilldale Hornets 1st grade Black HC
Agree Agree x 1 View List

guest3912

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #4 on: October 09, 2016, 01:54:58 pm »
Wish I'd taken bets on the replies I was going to get.  I'd be a rich man.  "Why aren't you coaching?"  " Pick up a whistle and volunteer your hours away from your family..."  "Before you complain...... Volunteer." 

On the surface, all those comments are relevant, but in fact, they are all misplaced.  My main question is this:  What is it that I outlined you think is wrong?  (1.) Coaches blaming kids for losses instead of taking responsibility for not preparing them properly?  (2.)  Too much talking and not enough productive drilling?  (3.) Failing to develop ALL players by relegating them to "dummy squads," effectively making them blocking dummies for their more talented team members?  (4.) Lack of competitive drills to discern the relative talents of individuals? 

Going back to the premise that if you're not coaching, you shouldn't be complaining: 

(1.)  I HAVE coached - I've coached city champion teams at both the youth league and junior high level.   I've coached 2 state championship high school football teams. Unlike some, I don't imagine myself to know-it-all, nor expect adulation for spending more time with OTHER people's kids than I did with my own due to coaching.  I was fortunate to have good fellow coaches, good administrations, good parents, good team members, and most of all, a loyal, understanding wife who – yes – endured fans in the stands who loudly attacked her husband during games. God Blessed me with those positives.
(2.)   I DID volunteer to coach a team in this league.  But since I had no son to bring to the table, my services weren't needed. Also, my views on proper conduct of team development were well known, and not acceptable to the existing leadership of the team.  I can understand that.  I don't object to that.  A head coach should have discretion as to his coaching staff.  Besides, I'm comfortable with not coaching now, as I'm older than most coaches, and physically not in my prime.
(3.)  I HAVE approached this coaching staff about these concerns, without significant change, in my opinion.  My only purpose in detailing my concerns in THIS forum is to provide specifics which may be considered by OTHER coaching staffs who are willing to evaluate their own policies and procedures.  However, if the only result is for coaches to kill the messenger, so to speak, it must be considered a failure.
(4.)  And specifically to you Blitz 16,  I don't even OWN a smart phone.  My flip phone is more than I need. ;D But I take offense at your statement, "You are the problem with youth athletics!" No.  Coaches that refuse to take responsibility for  inadequate preparation of their team, but instead choose to berate the players after a loss are the problem.  Coaches that believe they are the re-incarnation of Vince Lombardi are the problem.  Coaches that are coaches because their sons are talented and are acting as coaches only in return for their sons' joining a specific team are the problem.  Coaches that automatically assume a defensive - yea, even COMBATIVE attitude when confronted with the truth are the problem.  And coaches that eschew the fundamental development of ALL team members are the problem.  So don't declare that someone from outside the system is the problem when your own house needs cleaning.  I know. of some OUTSTANDING coaches in these leagues, but when I speak out against some who lack something in coaching knowledge and abilities, *I* become the problem.  <S>

What I am getting at in all this rhetoric is, to improve, we must ALL be willing to evaluate our own actions and behaviors on behalf of what is best for the kids.  Egos and personal agendas get in the way of such assessments.  For myself, I need to give more credit to the coaching staffs for the GOOD that they are accomplishing, rather  than concentrating on the problems I see.

Your shot, fellas..................   ;)
Like Like x 1 View List

guest2992

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #5 on: October 09, 2016, 02:47:25 pm »
To be honest there are not enough good coaches.  If you take out the daddy ball side of coaching from youth football there will not be enough coaches.  Or, this is what we have always been told.  It is a volunteer basis so you are going to get what you get.  The fall back excuse is always, "Pick up a whistle and you do it if it is so easy!"  This is still rec football it isn't competitive and the bottom line is that the INFC wants as many kids to play as possible.  This puts the kids, family, and coaches in a bad situation.  This will be my last year coaching after 7 years of coaching.  I can count on 1 hand the number of coaches I have seen that are truly coaches.  I see a lot more guys who sign up to coach, and do nothing more than stand around with a blocking pad, or shoot the **** for 2 hours 3 nights a week.  Maybe they don't know any better?  Or, the coach who is only coaching their own child.  Or the coach who is coaching to make sure their child is a starter or in a glamour position.  Don't get me wrong I appreciate all these guys giving up their time to help kids.  If it wasn't for all the volunteer coaches a lot of these kids wouldn't be allowed to play football and  the INFC wouldn't be able to make their payrolls.  A lot of things are wrong the way the INFC is ran, but one thing right is the amount of people who volunteer whether their intentions are in the right place or not.  We need more good coaches and less sports agents out on the field.  I think it also starts with the high school coaching staffs.  The high school coaches should be more involved at the youth level taking ownership of the programs, and making sure their next generation of players are taught the right way to block, run, and tackle.   just my 2 cents.

guest3572

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #6 on: October 09, 2016, 05:47:17 pm »
I understand where you coming from. So it a no win situation. If parent truly not happy then they can pull their child out. I am not a coach but a father of the player. Many times I have to hold my tongue and just continue support my son loves for football   
Agree Agree x 1 View List

guest3912

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #7 on: October 10, 2016, 02:37:16 pm »
BINGO, Mr. Stoops!   I agree with most everything you've posted here.  It's obvious you've "Seen the Elephant," to quote an old military phrase. 

The one thing we DO disagree upon is your statement that INFC is recreational and not competitive.  Having directed a youth association that included basketball,  I realize the INTENT of the programs are recreational, but the end product was VERY competitive.  I believe that to be the case with pretty much all youth “rec” programs, including those of the INFC.  Nothing wrong with that, actually, though the purity of recreational activities must be preserved for the welfare of the youth who need the social/physical values embedded within such youth organizations.  Thus, it becomes absolutely IMPERATIVE that coaches insure ALL participants benefit from the youth athletic/activity organization.  Therein lies the rub.  My experience has been, MOST coaches are more competitive than recreation oriented.  Especially the coach who is there because his kid is playing for that team.  Again, nothing wrong with that, basically, as long as the HEAD COACH makes sure the recreational aspects are included for those not yet so talented.

Yeah, we all can see flaws – perceived or real – in the INFC program.  No organization which encompasses such an abundant number of youth and the infrastructure required can avoid controversy and even criticism.  Just the policies, procedures, and rules alone are so intricately developed to insure the recreational aspect of the program is foremost.  Many who are advocates for the competitive position, however, want success on the field of play to be emphasized.  I seldom find myself criticizing the INFC, as I am familiar with their daunting task.

One area you mentioned I feel is especially important to cultivate in the INFC program is the involvement of high school coaches in the INFC infrastructure.  In my opinion, not many HS staffs have much involvement.  To their own detriment, I believe.  Pre-season clinics are available, but in MY opinion, seem to be more related to economics than long-term improvement of the youth.  I may be totally wrong in this, as I'm not as familiar with those efforts as are others.  Regardless, the influences and support of high school coaching staffs would be most beneficial.

Perhaps I should end this with the assurance that in no way am I disparaging all INFC coaches!  Over the past years, I've observed many admirable coaches and teams which benefited from what I call “life skills” imparted by those coaches.  Enjoyable, productive experiences have/will encourage kids of all levels of talent to continue to participate, and with the help of quality coaches, improve to the point of being valuable members of higher level teams.  Thank you, INFC, for providing those opportunities to the youth in our communities.

guest3912

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #8 on: October 10, 2016, 02:51:33 pm »
OUFOOTBALL75, it is encouraging to see that your prime concern is the continued enjoyment of football by your son.  :)  But it is discouraging that the only choice available regarding bad experiences with teams seems to be removal of the young man from the program.  And your comment about holding your tongue strikes close to home, as many of us who watch INFC football have similar feelings.  When confronted by situations that do not provide opportunities for ALL young men to learn and improve, however, THIS observer is not so disciplined.  Thus these posts at the risk of condemnation by others.

FootballOCD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1588
  • Karma: +157/-57
  • Making Champions on and off the field!
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #9 on: October 10, 2016, 10:02:41 pm »
After your explanation like I first said I could understand your grief! And take back my question of why aren't you coaching.

You do have strong valent reality points, my only thing is so many parents that haven't tried to coach get on here and complain and that is still my question to that type of "Player Agent" that's my name for parents lol.

And the problem with youth sports is parents for the most part ...from 6u to HS. And the second most is a youth coach coaching for the wrong reasons and thinking they know it all....in Any Sport.

This is my 13th yr (coached before had kids) and I do understand what your saying...some coaches can learn from others and some egos won't let them!! Shoot with your credentials you can come coach for me any day!!
Lets Eat!

5th grade Pryor

A CHAMPION is simply someone who did NOT give up when they wanted to."--Tom Landry,

LEAVE NO DOUBT!!!!

Shhhhhh don't tell nobody....

guest3925

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #10 on: October 11, 2016, 10:01:09 am »
I would have to agree ^^^^with how the parents act. They get mad bc your not a good enough coach or yell to much but yet they dont help with drills or anything. They like to complain to each other or under their breath. Coaches are volunteers. Yes some may not know as much football as the other but they are wanting to coach their child and be apart of something they are doing. This isnt the NFL they are not going out there to win the super bowl. Winning is always nice but these are children. When parent flips out and say they are done since their KG team isnt winning it just shows how they really are and its probably a good thing they are not coaching. I say KG bc thats what mostly the team is made of. Coaches can do their best a trying to get their team to listen but when the children are out there constatly talking, hitting, touching each other its hard to coach when all your doing is telling them to stop, quit and listen. Then those parents that are the complainers are just sitting over there not getting onto their child to listen and pay attention.

Strategy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1450
  • Karma: +204/-62
  • TYAA White 3rd Grade and TYAA Blue 5th Grade
  • Location: Catoosa
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #11 on: October 13, 2016, 03:04:38 pm »
I haven't been able to read all the comments and probably won't, but I can tell you that I for one have been and still am guilty of some of the problems with Youth Coaching that you have stated. I have spent way too much time during practice discussing game plans that should have already been discussed before practice or should be discussed after practice. I have spent way too much time "Installing" game day preparations for the upcoming opponent. As I have predetermined who was going to play where and why they were going to play there without trying other kids out at those positions. Also, I have been the coach that would drill my "star" players more than my "12 play kids".

I evaluate my coaching several times through out the season every season and try to become a better coach from it. I have been coaching Youth Football for 5 years and Wrestling for 6. So I have grown up as a Coach, Parent, and Husband through these few years. I can honestly say without any guidelines telling me what to do and what not to do I have had Rough times and I have had Good times. I don't remember losses and I don't remember wins from my first years and I can assume I won't remember today's losses and wins here in a few more years, but I can tell you this, I remember each kid I have ever coached and I remember where they were before I coached them and how far they have gone since they have been with me. I remember picking them up from their homes where they didn't stay more than a month or 2 at a time. I remember kids staying the night and having nerf gun fights with them all night then we're all tired come the next morning when it's game day. I would do just about anything for each and every single kid on my team even if they are not the "Star" player. I have learned so much from my mistakes in the way I have coached over the years and I have corrected so much too. I have been very blessed to have the coaching staff that I have now which allows us to put our heads together as volunteer parents who have never played more than the HS level of football and come up with great practice plans that will make a difference in our kids when they get to their HS coach. I'm not perfect, but I do believe that I have a lot to learn still yet and that the way we coach our team is beneficial and has almost done a 180 since the first couple years of coaching.


If I could give anyone advise that is a new coach I would say use the material available to you if you don't have someone to "Mentor" you. USA Football has been very useful and just be a go getter for information it's out there. If you lose a game don't worry, just figure out why you lost and fix it. If your team isn't tackling well then teach them proper tackling and find a fun drill that they can do 1000 times if that's what it takes. Proper drilling and lots of reps per kid is a lot more important than winning your ball game Saturday. Keep consistent, coach with a Smile 24/7. I have said this many times, even if you think they're not watching you they are so what you do is what they will do. They feed off your attitude, your gestures, your Smile. Make them want to look for you after they made a tackle just so they can run over with excitement and give you a high five because once you have their attention like that from then on you are their future, you are who they are when they get older. Your only as good as your team so coach them all up and watch how much better they become.


Like I said I have been this guy the Original Post is talking and still am this guy, but I do believe every minute I am out on the field and off the field I do my best to correct my coaching and my coaches coaching to make us better so we can teach our kids how to play football and not just yell at them on Saturdays with stuff like "Tackle!" "Run Harder" "ARE YOU SCARED!" Instead we try to be more informative and helpful to the players. I hope you all can read this guys post and really understand what he is saying, I don't believe he is trying to be disrespectful and I don't believe he is just trolling. What he says has a lot of meaning and is something I think about all the time even with my own team.

Thanks for the Post, it was about time I stepped back and evaluated my actions as a coach this year.


~ Strategy
Coach Hargrove
Catoosa 4th Grade HC

TYAA White Bulldogs 3rd Grade
TYAA Blue Bulldogs 5th Grade

~ Strategy
Like Like x 2 View List

Sandite Strong

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 19
  • Karma: +7/-1
  • 918-237-6451
  • Location: Sand Springs
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #12 on: October 14, 2016, 08:06:44 am »
Once again, Strategy took the words out of my mouth. Yes thank you Been There! I think that most of us coaches need to take a step back and evaluate our methods all the time. The only way to get better as a coach and person is to accept your mistakes and fix them, and how can you teach our youth to do that if you aren't doing it yourself. Kudos to you and thanks again for this post.
HC Sandites
Proud dad of #10

guest3912

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #13 on: October 14, 2016, 09:13:03 am »
Strategy, from your post, I'm thinkin' you're the kind of guy I'd like to have coaching ALL the INFC teams.   :) :D There ARE a good # of caring, dedicated coaches who are capable of more than chastising their teams for not winning.  And your involvement with other sports over such a long period of time is admirable.  But what impressed me most is the mention of involvement with your team outside the actual football practices/games.  THOSE are the positive influences on the life-skills I mentioned previously.

Thanks for what you - and those like you - do for our youth.  As a former teacher myself, I quickly recognize the difference in the ones who are there for the right reasons.

guest3912

  • Guest
Re: Don't blame kids for poor coaching............
« Reply #14 on: October 14, 2016, 09:24:42 am »
Sandite Strong, it is refreshing to see coaches like yourself get past the old "YOU are the problem with youth athletics," and "why aren't YOU coaching?" mantras.  Sincere self-evaluation is crucial in ANY endeavor, but when it comes to interacting positively with our YOUTH, it is almost mandatory.

Oh, and by the way, your Charles Page victory over Muskogee last night was perhaps the best HS football game I've ever seen!  And I've seen a few.  We try to pick the best HS football match-up in the area every week, and BOY, am I glad we decided to go to Muskogee last night!   ;D
Like Like x 1 View List