My prediction...Man thats a tough one
If Hilldale can disrupt their rhythm offensively by being aggressive at the line of scrimmage then I think I would give Hilldale the slight edge. If Catoosa can be strong up front, block and get the edge i would lean towards Catoosa. This is GOTW this week without a doubt.
I will lean Hilldale for the fact that I think their best players play in positions to truly disrupt the offense. But then again I would not be shocked at all if Catoosa wins.